Florida Propane Supplier Guide
Menu
Request delivery

Tractor Supply Co.

Updated 2026-08-04 · 2,934 reviewed · 485 listed · Scored from 319 Google reviews · How we rank ›

4.2(319) 71 composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified Publishes prices moderate
Cylinder Refill & ExchangeResidential Propane DeliveryAutomatic Delivery & Tank MonitoringCommercial & Industrial Propane Supply
Tractor Supply Co.
Price
moderate
Services
Cylinder Refill & Exchange, Residential Propane Delivery, Automatic Delivery & Tank Monitoring
Reviews
319

What recent reviews say

Staff here are helpful when engaged, with clean stores and solid inventory for farm and pet needs. The main friction centers on propane service: managers refuse refills citing weak weather excuses late in the day, and delivery coordination breaks down on large orders with staff disappearing and paperwork lost. A sister location nearby handles both better.

Praised for
  • helpful staff willing to assist in difficult conditions
  • clean store with good inventory
  • friendly vet clinic and pet services
  • reliable propane refill when available
Watch-outs
  • propane refill refused late in day on weak safety grounds
  • inconsistent service quality and arbitrary cutoff times
  • slow delivery and poor communication on large orders
  • staff indifference during disputes
on-time-deliveryresponsive-dispatchfriendly-driverspoor-communicationlong-wait-times
Best for: farmers and pet owners buying supplies; less reliable for urgent propane refills near closing time.
Think twice if: you rely on propane refills close to their closing time or need fast delivery coordination for large orders.

Strengths

  • willing to help load and assist customers in bad weather
  • clean store, strong inventory for farm and pet needs
  • on-site vet clinic and pet wash services

Worth knowing

  • Manager Mike cited lightning as reason to refuse propane refill when weather was clear and distant
  • staff disappeared for over an hour during large delivery without communication
  • one customer reported propane refill refused at 8:05 PM when store closes at 9:00 PM
  • sister location in Venice handles similar requests without issue

What reviews say by service

Cylinder Refill & Exchange
Managers inconsistently refuse refills in late afternoon or on weak weather grounds; a nearby store handles the same requests without issue.
Commercial & Industrial Propane Supply
Large deliveries suffer from slow staff response, missing paperwork, and lack of communication despite agreed handoff protocol.

How it compares

  • Rated 4.2 against a 3.57 average across the 88 cylinder refill & exchange businesses listed here.
  • Has more Google reviews than 97% of the businesses in this directory.

How we scored this

Scoring Method
Star rating 44
Review volume 100
Review recency 100
Review sentiment 48
Profile completeness 100
Verification 30

Rating breakdown

5
209
4
51
3
10
2
14
1
35

Common questions

Can I refill my propane tank close to closing time?
Reviewers report staff refuse refills within an hour of closing (9 PM) and sometimes earlier on weak safety grounds, citing distant weather. Call ahead or visit the Venice location instead.
Do you handle large commercial deliveries?
The store accepts them but coordination has been poor: staff disappeared mid-delivery for over an hour without updates, and delivery paperwork went missing.
Request a quote

Similar propane suppliers nearby

Amerigas Propane Exchange
34 low data

Amerigas Propane Exchange

No rating yet

Amerigas Propane Exchange operates in Sarasota with seven-day service availability. Their website lists propane delivery, tank installation, grill tank exchange, AutoGas conversion, and agricultural services for residential and commercial customers. Review evidence is limited.

Cylinder Refill & Exchange24/7 Emergency Propane ServiceResidential Propane Delivery
View profile
Blue Rhino Propane Exchange
30 low data

Blue Rhino Propane Exchange

No rating yet

Review evidence for Blue Rhino Propane Exchange is limited. The business states it offers tank exchanges, home delivery, and commercial propane supply in Sarasota, operating daily. No customer reviews are available to assess service quality, reliability, or pricing.

Residential Propane DeliveryCommercial & Industrial Propane Supply
View profile
Blue Rhino Propane Exchange
30 low data

Blue Rhino Propane Exchange

No rating yet

Review evidence is limited. Blue Rhino operates from Sarasota and their website claims to offer propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business delivery in customer service areas.

Cylinder Refill & ExchangeResidential Propane DeliveryPropane Tank Installation & Leasing
View profile

Own this business? Get featured

Own or market a business here? Ask about featured placement and advertising on this directory. Your message goes straight to the directory team.

Last updated 2026-08-04