Best propane suppliers in Fort Myers
This list ranks the 15 top propane suppliers in Fort Myers using our methodology, which weighs Google rating, review volume, recency and sentiment rather than star rating alone. It covers everything from dedicated gas companies to farm stores, hardware chains and wholesale clubs that also handle tank fills and exchanges.
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to propane supplier, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tractor Supply Co. | 82 | 4.5 (890) | moderate | One-stop farm and propane runs |
| 2 | Sunshine Ace Hardware - San Carlos | 81 | 4.5 (245) | — | Problem-solving hardware and propane trips |
| 3 | Tractor Supply Co. | 79 | 4.4 (684) | moderate | Convenient North Fort Myers errands |
| 4 | Blossman Gas | 77 | 4.4 (70) | — | Dedicated propane service with fast dispatch |
| 5 | South Florida Gas | 72 | 4.4 (64) | — | App-based tank monitoring and emergency fills |
| 6 | BJ's Wholesale Club | 72 | 3.9 (454) | moderate | Lowest propane and fuel prices |
| 7 | Tractor Supply Co. | 67 | 4.5 (31) | — | Newer store with pet wash extras |
| 8 | U-Haul Moving & Storage of Cape Coral and North Fort Myers | 67 | 3.9 (241) | — | Propane plus moving equipment in one trip |
| 9 | U-Haul Moving & Storage of South Fort Myers | 66 | 3.9 (199) | inexpensive | Vehicle rental with occasional propane |
| 10 | Affordable Secure Storage - Ft Myers | 64 | 4.5 (20) | — | Storage customers who also need propane nearby |
| 11 | U-Haul Moving & Storage at Colonial Blvd | 63 | 3.7 (337) | — | High-volume rental location, mixed track record |
| 12 | REDBONES III Liquor & Smoke | 62 | 4 (159) | — | Late-night convenience stop |
| 13 | United Rentals | 58 | 4.2 (16) | — | Occasional equipment rental need |
| 14 | Jacobs Gas Propane Refill & Delivery | 57 | 4.1 (13) | — | Drive-through cylinder refills |
| 15 | United Rentals | 57 | 4.4 (15) | — | Backup equipment rental option |
1. Tractor Supply Co.
4.5 (890 reviews)score 82/100moderate
This location tops the list on the strength of a large, recent review base and consistently friendly service, with customers pointing to fair propane prices alongside a clean, well-stocked store. It works well for anyone who wants to combine a propane fill with farm, pet or garage supply shopping in one stop.
- Friendly, knowledgeable staff
- Clean, well-stocked facility
- Fair propane pricing
- Wide farm and pet supply range
Watch out: A few reviewers flagged understaffing and order fulfillment mistakes.
Services: residential propane delivery, autofill monitoring, emergency propane service, autogas propane cylinder refill · Price: moderate
2. Sunshine Ace Hardware - San Carlos
4.5 (245 reviews)score 81/100
This Sunshine Ace location earns a high-confidence score built on 245 reviews and a strong reputation for staff who actually solve problems rather than just process sales. Named employees like Brian, Mitch and Emma show up repeatedly in reviews for going beyond the basic ask, which is a good sign for anyone with a specific propane or hardware need.
- Staff solve complex requests, not just transactions
- Stocks hardware, fishing gear, grills and propane together
- Home delivery available
- Clean, organized store
Watch out: One review mentioned friction between management and staff, and window repair service was inconsistent for at least one customer.
Services: autofill monitoring
3. Tractor Supply Co.
4.4 (684 reviews)score 79/100moderate
With 684 reviews and a solid 4.4 rating, this North Fort Myers Tractor Supply is a reliable pick for routine propane and farm supply runs at moderate prices. Staff friendliness comes up often, though it trails the top picks slightly on inventory consistency.
- Friendly, professional staff
- Convenient North Fort Myers location
- Moderate pricing
- Wide farm and ranch supply selection
Watch out: Stock gaps and occasional merchandise discrepancies at checkout have been reported.
Services: residential propane delivery, autofill monitoring, emergency propane service, autogas propane cylinder refill · Price: moderate
4. Blossman Gas
4.4 (70 reviews)score 77/100
Blossman Gas stands out as a specialist propane provider with the highest sentiment score on this list, driven by reports of same-day emergency fills and technicians who arrive on time. One reviewer describes staff correcting a competitor's faulty tank reading rather than upselling, which speaks to a level of trust that general retailers don't typically earn.
- Same-day emergency fills and fast dispatch
- Named staff (Jennifer, Cindy, Michael Moore, Alex, Bruce, Herbie) build repeat trust
- Handles fireplace and generator service alongside propane
- Reputation for honest, consultative sales
Watch out: Review volume is moderate (70 reviews), so the sample is smaller than the retail chains above it.
Services: residential propane delivery, autofill monitoring, propane tank installation, emergency propane service
5. South Florida Gas
4.4 (64 reviews)score 72/100
South Florida Gas has a high-confidence score thanks to strong review consistency, with staff like Nikki, Christine and Tracey called out repeatedly for handling emergencies and walking new customers through account setup. The tank monitoring app and after-hours response are real conveniences, though the business has gone through a bumpy ownership transition under Thompson Gas.
- Emergency response after hours and on weekends
- Tank monitoring app for auto-fill convenience
- Same-day delivery when available
- Named staff build long-term relationships
Watch out: The flat $44 per-tank refill rate (even for partial fills) frustrates customers used to per-gallon pricing, and some report scheduling breakdowns since the ownership change.
Services: autogas propane cylinder refill, commercial industrial propane, propane tank installation, residential propane delivery
6. BJ's Wholesale Club
3.9 (454 reviews)score 72/100moderate
BJ's Wholesale Club draws a large volume of reviews (454) and repeated mentions of the best fuel and propane pricing in the area, backed by staff who help load heavy items without being asked. The rating sits lower than others here, largely due to friction at membership and receipt checks rather than the propane service itself.
- Competitive fuel and propane prices
- Staff assist with heavy-item loading
- Same-day delivery and curbside pickup
- Long-term member loyalty reported
Watch out: Receipt-check procedures at exit have drawn complaints, including one dispute involving accessibility concerns.
Services: residential propane delivery, autofill monitoring, emergency propane service, commercial industrial propane · Price: moderate
7. Tractor Supply Co.
4.5 (31 reviews)score 67/100
This Fort Myers Tractor Supply gets solid marks (4.5 from 31 reviews) for a clean, well-organized layout and decent feed and supply stock, though the review base is smaller than its sister locations. It's a reasonable option if you're already nearby, with pet wash stations as a bonus.
- New, well-organized store layout
- Pet wash stations with supplies included
- Friendly, helpful staff
- Convenient location
Watch out: Some customers reported rude phone interactions and unresolved online order cancellations.
Services: residential propane delivery, autofill monitoring, emergency propane service, autogas propane cylinder refill
8. U-Haul Moving & Storage of Cape Coral and North Fort Myers
3.9 (241 reviews)score 67/100
This U-Haul location pairs propane refills with truck and trailer rental, and reviewers frequently mention staff who know the equipment well and move fast. Sentiment is more mixed than the top picks, with some describing safety concerns around the facility layout.
- Staff knowledgeable on specific equipment
- Fast service and turnaround
- Competitive pricing
- Large facility with wide selection
Watch out: Some reviewers cited facility safety concerns and inconsistent handling of damage claims.
Services: residential propane delivery, autofill monitoring, propane tank installation, emergency propane service
9. U-Haul Moving & Storage of South Fort Myers
3.9 (199 reviews)score 66/100inexpensive
Staff here get consistent praise for friendliness and quick truck rental processing, but propane specifically is the weak link: several reviewers arrived to find no one available to fill tanks. Better suited to moving needs than as a primary propane stop.
- Friendly, helpful staff
- Efficient vehicle pickup and drop-off
- One-stop moving supplies
- Inexpensive pricing on rentals
Watch out: Propane refill availability is unreliable, and truck rentals carry surprise fuel and equipment fees.
Services: residential propane delivery, autofill monitoring, propane tank installation, emergency propane service · Price: inexpensive
10. Affordable Secure Storage - Ft Myers
4.5 (20 reviews)score 64/100
Affordable Secure Storage earns a strong 4.5 rating with on-site manager Kevin named repeatedly for going above and beyond, though the review count (20) is on the lower side, so treat the score as a smaller-sample signal. It's primarily a storage facility with a loyal, long-term customer base.
- Friendly, hands-on on-site manager
- Affordable pricing
- Clean and secure facility
- Long customer retention
Watch out: Low review volume means less data to confirm consistency over time.
Services: commercial industrial propane
11. U-Haul Moving & Storage at Colonial Blvd
3.7 (337 reviews)score 63/100
This Colonial Blvd U-Haul has the largest review base among the moving/storage entries (337) and gets credit for clean facilities and efficient check-in, with staff like Kash and Frost singled out for good service. But the complaint pattern around damaged belongings and denied claims is serious enough to weigh against it for anyone renting more than a propane tank.
- Clean, well-maintained vehicles and facilities
- Efficient rental check-in process
- Staff go the extra step (van upgrades, equipment swaps)
- Property maintenance improving per recent reviews
Watch out: Multiple reports of damaged customer property and denied insurance claims during disputes.
Services: residential propane delivery, autogas propane cylinder refill, commercial industrial propane
12. REDBONES III Liquor & Smoke
4 (159 reviews)score 62/100
REDBONES III is primarily a liquor and smoke shop, and propane services aren't specifically mentioned in its reviews, so this listing rests on limited, indirect evidence. Staff friendliness is a consistent theme, but the score reflects a low-confidence, mixed sentiment profile.
- Friendly, polite staff
- Open late hours
- Decent liquor selection
Watch out: Reviewers report unanswered phone calls, high pricing and hidden credit card fees; propane specifics are unverified.
Services: residential propane delivery, commercial industrial propane
13. United Rentals
4.2 (16 reviews)score 58/100
United Rentals on this listing gets a positive but small sample of reviews (16) praising quick, hassle-free pickups and responsive staff. It's a reasonable fallback if you need rental equipment alongside propane, though the low review count limits confidence.
- Responsive staff support
- Fast pickup and return
- Wide equipment range
Watch out: Some reviewers received beat-up equipment and ran into billing disputes over damage.
Services: residential propane delivery, commercial industrial propane
14. Jacobs Gas Propane Refill & Delivery
4.1 (13 reviews)score 57/100
Jacobs Gas is a small, local propane specialist with a low review count (13) but generally positive sentiment around fast, drive-through refills and direct technician contact for emergencies. It's worth a look for routine cylinder refills, though pricing complaints on cylinders stand out.
- Drive-through refill convenience
- Same-day emergency dispatch
- Established local operator, licensed and insured
- Personalized quotes for setup
Watch out: One reviewer paid over $6 per gallon for cylinder refills, and a commercial quote follow-up reportedly took weeks.
Services: residential propane delivery, autofill monitoring, propane tank installation, emergency propane service
15. United Rentals
4.4 (15 reviews)score 57/100
This United Rentals location shows friendly staff and quick delivery in most reviews, but a low review count (15) and a notable complaint about equipment malfunction and management response keep confidence low. Best treated as a secondary option rather than a first call.
- Friendly, professional staff
- Quick equipment delivery and pickup
- Proper safety protocols reported
Watch out: At least one significant complaint about equipment malfunction and unresolved management response.
Services: residential propane delivery, commercial industrial propane