THE BEST 15 PROPANE SUPPLIERS IN FORT MYERS FLORIDA

★★★★★4.5 (898 reviews)score 81/100moderate

81/100

This location tops the list on the strength of a large, recent review base and consistently friendly, organized service. Shoppers come for the farm, pet, and outdoor gear at fair prices, and most leave happy with the staff's attentiveness.

• Friendly and knowledgeable staff
• Wide selection of farm, pet, and outdoor gear
• Clean, well-organized store
• Fair prices

Watch out: A handful of reviewers flagged product quality issues and one instance of a manager giving inconsistent stock information.

Services: commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery, autogas propane cylinder refill · Price: moderate

★★★★☆4.4 (687 reviews)score 80/100moderate

80/100

Sitting just behind its sister store, this Tractor Supply earns praise for a convenient location and a team that rural and farm customers describe as professional and fair on pricing. Review volume is strong and sentiment leans clearly positive.

• Friendly, professional staff
• Convenient, easy-access location
• Fair pricing and solid selection
• Good fit for farm and pet supply runs

Watch out: One shopper flagged empty shelves and a checkout pricing error, though the store responded quickly.

Services: commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery, autofill monitoring, autogas propane cylinder refill · Price: moderate

★★★★☆4.4 (73 reviews)score 77/100

77/100

Blossman is the highest-confidence pick among the true propane specialists on this list, with a reputation built since 1951 for treating small residential refills with the same care as big commercial jobs. Named technicians and an online account system make routine service and emergency fills easy to manage.

• Named technicians (Alex, Michael, Bruce, Jennifer) praised repeatedly
• Online account access with dispatch often within 24 hours
• Skilled fireplace, water heater, and generator tank installs
• Serving Southwest Florida since 1951

Services: propane tank installation, emergency propane service, commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery

★★★★☆3.9 (244 reviews)score 71/100

71/100

This U-Haul location pairs propane service with moving and hitch work, and most customers describe the staff as knowledgeable and the grounds as clean. It scores lower than the top picks mainly on rating strength rather than any single major complaint.

• Professional, knowledgeable staff
• Clean, well-kept facility
• Fast turnaround on hitch installs
• Competitive pricing

Watch out: Some reviewers describe a cramped lot and unhelpful handling when disputing equipment damage.

Services: propane tank installation, emergency propane service, commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery

★★★★☆3.9 (470 reviews)score 68/100moderate

68/100

BJ's draws a steady stream of members for competitive pricing and convenience, with regulars noting friendly staff. Sentiment here is mixed rather than uniformly positive, so it sits mid-pack.

• Competitive pricing
• Convenient location
• Quality products
• Friendly staff noted by regulars

Watch out: A serious racial profiling complaint surfaced alongside otherwise positive feedback, and membership is required.

Services: residential propane delivery · Price: moderate

★★★★☆4.3 (65 reviews)score 67/100

67/100

South Florida Gas earns a high-confidence score thanks to named staff, like Nikki, Christine, and Terry, who get repeated shoutouts for going the extra mile, plus a tank-monitoring app that takes the guesswork out of refills. Install and repair work reviews well, though the business side has gotten rockier since being acquired by Thompson Gas.

• Same-day emergency delivery
• Tank-monitoring app for peace of mind
• Named staff who follow up personally
• Comprehensive install work including trenching

Watch out: Refills are charged per tank rather than per gallon, and scheduling/communication have slipped since the Thompson Gas acquisition.

Services: residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, autofill monitoring, autogas propane cylinder refill

★★★★☆3.9 (202 reviews)score 66/100inexpensive

66/100

Regulars single out staff like John and William for attentive, efficient service on pickups and drop-offs. The score is held back by recurring billing disputes and at least one customer turned away for propane near closing time.

• Attentive staff known by name (John, William)
• Efficient pickups and drop-offs
• Staff willing to correct errors after escalation

Watch out: One customer was turned away for propane an hour before closing because no one was available to fill tanks, and billing/refund disputes come up repeatedly.

Services: propane tank installation, emergency propane service, commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery · Price: inexpensive

★★★★★4.5 (20 reviews)score 65/100

65/100

This facility gets consistent praise for being clean, affordable, and well run over many years, with on-site manager Kevin named repeatedly for going above and beyond. The score carries lower confidence since it's based on a smaller pool of reviews.

• On-site manager Kevin praised repeatedly
• Affordable rates
• Clean, secure facility
• Long-term customer retention

Services: autofill monitoring, residential propane delivery

★★★★☆3.7 (345 reviews)score 63/100

63/100

On a good day, staff here are warm and transactions move fast, which keeps this location's sentiment from tipping fully negative. But staffing shortages create real bottlenecks on other days, pulling the score down.

• Friendly, helpful staff on good days
• Quick service when fully staffed
• Clean facilities
• Smooth rental transactions

Watch out: Staffing shortages have led to long waits, rude interactions, and inconsistent service on other visits.

Services: commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery, autofill monitoring, autogas propane cylinder refill

★★★★☆4.2 (44 reviews)score 62/100

62/100

This Tractor Supply offers on-site propane refills alongside a popular dog wash station and birdseed selection, drawing a loyal repeat crowd. Sentiment is mixed thanks to complaints about one staff member and pricing on some items, so weigh this against the two higher-scoring Tractor Supply locations above.

• On-site propane refills
• Popular dog wash station
• Good birdseed selection
• Friendly checkout staff on good visits

Watch out: Multiple reviewers cite rudeness from a specific staff member and inflated prices on some products.

Services: commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery, autofill monitoring, autogas propane cylinder refill

★★★★☆4 (159 reviews)score 62/100

62/100

REDBONES III sits low on this list with limited evidence: propane service itself isn't mentioned directly in available reviews, and the score reflects a lower-confidence read. What reviews exist praise the staff and late hours.

• Friendly, polite staff
• Open late hours
• Decent liquor selection

Watch out: Some reviewers report unresponsive phone lines, high pricing, and hidden credit card fees.

Services: residential propane delivery

★★★★☆4.2 (16 reviews)score 59/100

59/100

This United Rentals location gets credit for quick, hassle-free rentals and responsive staff, though the score reflects a small review sample so treat it as a lighter-confidence read.

• Responsive staff
• Fast pickup and return
• Wide equipment range

Watch out: A few customers encountered worn equipment and billing disagreements over damaged items.

Services: propane tank installation, commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery

★★★★☆4.4 (15 reviews)score 58/100

58/100

Reviewers describe friendly, fast service and proper safety protocols here, but the small review count and at least one flagged equipment issue keep confidence lower than the top picks.

• Friendly, professional staff
• Quick unload and delivery
• Proper safety protocols followed

Watch out: At least one reviewer reported an equipment malfunction with a slow management response.

Services: propane tank installation, commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery

★★★★☆4.1 (13 reviews)score 57/100

57/100

Jacobs Gas is a dedicated local propane operator offering drive-through convenience and same-day emergency dispatch, but its score reflects a small review base and at least one pricing complaint.

• Drive-through refill convenience
• Same-day emergency dispatch
• Licensed and insured local operator
• Direct technician contact

Watch out: One reviewer paid over $6 per gallon for a cylinder refill and felt overcharged, and a commercial quote follow-up took weeks.

Services: propane tank installation, emergency propane service, commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery

★★★★☆4.2 (12 reviews)score 55/100

55/100

Named staff like Harley and Andrew Wilson deliver strong one-on-one service with fast exchanges and clean equipment, which is why this location makes the cut despite a small review count. The gap shows up after the sale, where follow-through gets shakier.

• Personalized service from named staff
• Fast, flexible exchanges
• Clean, well-maintained equipment

Watch out: Some buyers reported missed delivery dates and lost contact with their sales rep until management stepped in.

Services: propane tank installation, commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery