Best propane suppliers in Sarasota
We scored propane suppliers, tank exchange spots, and hardware/rental chains that offer propane in Sarasota using our methodology, which weighs rating, review volume, recency, and sentiment. This list covers everyone from dedicated gas companies to big-box exchange counters, ranked by that composite score.
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to propane supplier, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Flanders Gas Inc | 72 | 4.3 (64) | — | Fast, fair-priced refills |
| 2 | Tractor Supply Co. | 71 | 4.2 (319) | moderate | One-stop farm & pet run with propane |
| 3 | U-Haul Moving & Storage of North Sarasota | 68 | 3.8 (135) | — | Truck rental with propane on-site |
| 4 | Detweiler's Propane Gas Service, Lc | 64 | 3.9 (56) | — | Long-term customers & automatic refill |
| 5 | Suburban Propane | 64 | 3.8 (205) | — | Named technicians you can request |
| 6 | United Rentals | 64 | 4.3 (21) | — | Equipment rental with propane needs |
| 7 | U-Haul Moving & Storage of South Sarasota | 59 | 3.5 (207) | — | Simple truck/trailer rental |
| 8 | Midco Petroleum | 56 | 4.4 (14) | — | Legacy customers with existing accounts |
| 9 | Sunoco | 51 | 3.2 (37) | — | Fuel stop convenience, not propane |
| 10 | Propane Refill at U-Haul | 44 | 5 (1) | — | Quick U-Haul-station refill |
| 11 | Propane Refill at U-Haul | 37 | 3 (2) | — | RV/camper refills, if staff is trained |
| 12 | Amerigas Propane Exchange | 34 | — | — | Broad service range, unverified by reviews |
| 13 | Blue Rhino | 34 | — | — | Grill tank exchange convenience |
| 14 | Amerigas Propane Exchange | 30 | — | — | Statewide commercial supply, unverified |
| 15 | Propane Exchange at The Home Depot | 30 | — | — | Grab-and-go tank swap while shopping |
1. Flanders Gas Inc
4.3 (64 reviews)score 72/100
Flanders Gas posts the strongest composite score in Sarasota on the back of a 4.3-star rating across 64 reviews, with customers repeatedly calling out quick turnaround and honest per-gallon pricing rather than flat-fee exchange rates. It also holds up during hurricane season, when propane demand spikes and reliability matters most.
- Per-gallon pricing instead of flat exchange fees
- About a 5-minute refill turnaround
- Held up well during hurricane-season demand
- Local, established operation
Watch out: Billing still runs through phone-based processes; there's no online payment option yet.
Services: autogas propane cylinder refill, residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, emergency propane service
2. Tractor Supply Co.
4.2 (319 reviews)score 71/100moderate
Tractor Supply Co. draws a high volume of reviews (319) and a 4.2 rating, backed by a clean store, solid farm and pet inventory, and staff who pitch in even in rough weather. Propane service itself is the weak spot: refill availability and quality vary noticeably depending on which staff member and time of day you catch.
- Clean store with strong farm and pet inventory
- On-site vet clinic and pet wash
- Staff willing to help load in bad weather
- Reliable refills when the timing works out
Watch out: Refills can be refused late in the day on inconsistent safety grounds, and large delivery orders have had communication break down.
Services: autogas propane cylinder refill, residential propane delivery, autofill monitoring, commercial industrial propane · Price: moderate
3. U-Haul Moving & Storage of North Sarasota
3.8 (135 reviews)score 68/100
This North Sarasota U-Haul location earns a high-confidence score from 135 reviews and a 3.8 rating, with named staff like Aaron, Juan, and Colstan repeatedly singled out for going beyond the standard transaction. Rentals, trailers, and storage all get consistent praise for speed and cleanliness; it's the U-Box shipping side that drags on the rating.
- Friendly, efficient staff for rentals and storage
- Clean, well-organized facility
- Named employees consistently praised
- Open seven days a week
Watch out: U-Box customers have reported tracking failures and missed delivery dates; stick to local rentals if you want the smoothest experience.
Services: propane tank installation, residential propane delivery, commercial industrial propane
4. Detweiler's Propane Gas Service, Lc
3.9 (56 reviews)score 64/100
Detweiler's has been running in Sarasota for more than 65 years, and that history shows in five-star loyalty spanning over a decade from customers on its automatic refill plan. Staff members like Melanie, Ann, Marie, April, and Jeff get named repeatedly for responsiveness, though a minority of reviews mention communication gaps on installs.
- 65+ year operating history
- Automatic refill with convenient billing
- Named staff known for helpfulness
- Handles complex multi-connection installs
Watch out: A small number of customers report poor communication during install projects and occasional rude manager interactions.
Services: autogas propane cylinder refill, residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, emergency propane service
5. Suburban Propane
3.8 (205 reviews)score 64/100
Suburban Propane pulls the highest review volume on this list (205) and shows real strength in specific technicians who are patient, honest about declining unnecessary fills, and responsive to emergencies. The company-level pattern is rockier: unauthorized fill-ups, billing errors that take months to resolve, and emergency waits reported past six hours pull the overall sentiment to mixed.
- Named technicians praised for honesty and expertise
- Weekend and after-hours emergency response
- Online account setup available
- Some staff decline fills you don't actually need
Watch out: Billing mistakes and no-show appointments come up often enough to plan for slower resolution if something goes wrong.
Services: autogas propane cylinder refill, residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, emergency propane service
6. United Rentals
4.3 (21 reviews)score 64/100
United Rentals scores well despite a smaller review base (21 reviews, 4.3 rating), with recent feedback describing smooth pickups, well-maintained equipment, and staff willing to extend hours to hit a deadline. A few older complaints about last-minute cancellations exist, but they read as dated next to the stronger recent pattern.
- Competitive rates noted consistently
- Equipment kept in good condition
- Staff flexible on scheduling and delivery
- Online booking cuts down office paperwork
Watch out: A handful of older reviews mention reservations being cancelled without warning.
Services: residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, commercial industrial propane
7. U-Haul Moving & Storage of South Sarasota
3.5 (207 reviews)score 59/100
The South Sarasota U-Haul splits its 207 reviews roughly down the middle: straightforward truck and trailer rentals go smoothly, often with Manager Alicia or staffer Aaron called out by name, but propane refills and installs see more billing mix-ups and missed appointments. It's a reasonable option if you keep the transaction simple.
- Manager Alicia praised for professionalism
- Aaron noted for resolving problems
- Simple rentals handled efficiently
- Open seven days a week
Watch out: Propane refills and installations carry a higher chance of billing errors or missed appointments than basic rentals.
Services: autogas propane cylinder refill, residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, emergency propane service
8. Midco Petroleum
4.4 (14 reviews)score 56/100
Midco Petroleum built over a decade of loyalty with dependable delivery and hurricane-season emergency response, and it still earns a 4.4 rating. Recent reviews suggest the propane side of the business may have narrowed or stopped, so current availability is genuinely unclear.
- Family-owned with 10+ year customer relationships
- Emergency delivery during hurricanes historically praised
- Refers customers elsewhere when they can't help
- Courteous staff
Watch out: Recent reviews indicate they may no longer take new propane or generator accounts; confirm availability before relying on them.
Services: autogas propane cylinder refill, residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, autofill monitoring
9. Sunoco
3.2 (37 reviews)score 51/100
Sunoco is included as a fuel station carrying propane, but the 3.2 rating from 37 reviews points to real trust issues beyond gas: broken receipt machines, price spikes during peak travel, and alleged card fraud by staff all come up repeatedly. Convenience and fuel variety are the only consistent positives.
- Convenient location
- Fuel variety including Premium, Diesel, and Race Fuel
- Open seven days
Watch out: Multiple reviewers report overpricing, dirty facilities, and staff conduct problems including alleged card misuse.
Services: autogas propane cylinder refill, residential propane delivery, commercial industrial propane
10. Propane Refill at U-Haul
5 (1 reviews)score 44/100
This U-Haul propane refill point has just one review, a five-star mention of fast delivery, so treat the score as a starting point rather than a verdict. Published pricing and the U-Haul location make it an easy stop if you're already nearby.
- Fast service in the one review available
- Convenient U-Haul location
Watch out: Only one review exists, so there isn't enough evidence yet to judge consistency.
Services: autogas propane cylinder refill, residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, emergency propane service
11. Propane Refill at U-Haul
3 (2 reviews)score 37/100
With only two reviews, this U-Haul refill location shows a split result: one customer praised fast, accurate service, while another was turned away over a manager's misreading of tank certification rules and had to find refill elsewhere. It handles RV and camper tanks, but the sample is too small to call it dependable yet.
- Fast service reported in one review
- Accurate measurement noted
Watch out: One reviewer was refused service due to a staff misunderstanding of certification standards, with no good recovery offered.
Services: autogas propane cylinder refill, residential propane delivery, emergency propane service, commercial industrial propane
12. Amerigas Propane Exchange
score 34/100
This Amerigas location lists a wide menu including delivery, tank installation, grill tank exchange, AutoGas conversion, and agricultural service across seven-day hours, but there are zero reviews to confirm how any of it plays out in practice.
- Wide range of listed services
- Seven-day availability
- Covers both residential and commercial customers
Watch out: No reviews exist yet, so service quality is unverified.
Services: autogas propane cylinder refill, emergency propane service, residential propane delivery, commercial industrial propane
13. Blue Rhino
score 34/100
Blue Rhino covers the basic tank exchange and delivery need for homes and businesses around Sarasota, but with zero reviews on record there's no customer feedback yet to weigh against the service listing.
- Propane tank exchange available
- Serves both residential and commercial customers
Watch out: No review history is available to confirm real-world service quality.
Services: residential propane delivery, commercial industrial propane
14. Amerigas Propane Exchange
score 30/100
This Amerigas listing advertises a fuller commercial slate, including leak checks and tank recertification, delivery, cylinder exchange, and emergency service across Florida, but there's no review evidence yet to back any of it up locally.
Watch out: Zero reviews on record; treat listed services as unverified until you get a firsthand quote.
Services: autogas propane cylinder refill, residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, emergency propane service
15. Propane Exchange at The Home Depot
score 30/100
The Home Depot propane exchange cage is a familiar option if you're already picking up hardware, but there isn't enough recent review activity here to say anything reliable about consistency or service.
Watch out: No meaningful review history exists yet for this location's propane exchange.
Services: autogas propane cylinder refill, residential propane delivery, commercial industrial propane