Best propane suppliers in Tampa
This ranks the 15 highest-scoring propane suppliers in Tampa by our methodology, which weighs rating, review volume, recency, and sentiment together. It covers everything from retail tank exchange counters to full-service home delivery accounts, since most providers in this market overlap on both.
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to propane supplier, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tractor Supply Co. | 77 | 4.6 (891) | — | Quick in-store tank refill |
| 2 | BJ's Wholesale Club | 71 | 4.2 (425) | moderate | Bulk buyers with a membership |
| 3 | Tampa Live Poultry | 70 | 4.3 (186) | — | Neighborhood butcher-and-propane stop |
| 4 | U-Haul Moving & Storage at Gandy Blvd | 69 | 3.9 (138) | — | Propane plus trailer hitch work |
| 5 | True Value Rental of Brandon-Tampa FL | 68 | 4.4 (27) | — | Last-minute equipment and setup |
| 6 | U-Haul Moving & Storage at Citrus Park | 66 | 3.9 (197) | — | Straightforward rental with propane on the side |
| 7 | U-Haul Moving & Storage at Westchase | 64 | 3.7 (245) | — | Rentals when propane staffing lines up |
| 8 | U-Haul Moving & Storage of North Tampa | 63 | 3.7 (233) | — | Online booking convenience |
| 9 | U-Haul Moving & Storage of Historic Ybor City | 62 | 3.7 (204) | — | Downtown/Ybor propane access |
| 10 | U-Haul Moving & Storage of West Tampa | 60 | 3.5 (220) | — | On-site hitch install with rental |
| 11 | U-Haul Moving & Storage of East Tampa | 59 | 3.5 (172) | — | Reliable propane fills with named techs |
| 12 | Suburban Propane | 59 | 3.3 (263) | — | Full-service home delivery with autofill |
| 13 | U-Haul Moving & Storage at West Waters Ave | 59 | 3.3 (161) | inexpensive | Same-day trailer hitch fixes |
| 14 | United Rentals | 58 | 4.3 (19) | — | Equipment rental, improving track record |
| 15 | United Rentals | 56 | 3.8 (32) | — | Backup option, verify availability first |
1. Tractor Supply Co.
4.6 (891 reviews)score 77/100
Tractor Supply Co. leads the list on the strength of a 4.6 rating across 891 reviews, the highest volume-and-rating combination in this set. Most trips are described as fast and low-hassle, with fair prices and stock on hand, though the delivery side of the business (as opposed to walk-in tank refill) is where things occasionally go sideways.
- Wide selection at competitive prices
- Friendly, professional staff on the floor
- Convenient Tampa location
- In-store propane refill, no appointment needed
Watch out: Delivery orders draw complaints about long waits, poor communication, and merchandise arriving damaged.
Services: autofill monitoring, autogas propane cylinder refill
2. BJ's Wholesale Club
4.2 (425 reviews)score 71/100moderate
BJ's Wholesale Club pairs propane exchange with warehouse-club pricing, and members who've shopped there for years back up the reputation for value and friendly staff. It scores well on volume and recency, though recent reviews flag some inconsistency in how phone and delivery issues get handled.
- Competitive bulk pricing
- Friendly, helpful staff culture
- Wide product selection beyond propane
- Strong in-store atmosphere
Watch out: Delivery order errors and dismissive phone support show up in recent complaints.
Services: autofill monitoring, residential propane delivery, commercial industrial propane · Price: moderate
3. Tampa Live Poultry
4.3 (186 reviews)score 70/100
Tampa Live Poultry earns a 4.3 rating from 186 reviews as a smaller neighborhood operation where propane sits alongside fresh meat sales. Weekly repeat customers cite fair pricing and a clean shop, which carries real weight even though the review base is smaller than the chains above it.
- Consistently fresh meat and produce
- Friendly staff with repeat weekly customers
- Fair, transparent pricing
- Clean, well-kept store
Watch out: One reviewer reported an incomplete order, and there's a note on animal welfare conditions worth being aware of.
Services: residential propane delivery, commercial industrial propane
4. U-Haul Moving & Storage at Gandy Blvd
3.9 (138 reviews)score 69/100
The Gandy Blvd U-Haul stands out among this brand's Tampa locations for consistency, with a high-confidence score built on genuinely positive sentiment. Staff members Mike and Alexis get called out by name for fast hitch installs and for catching a real safety issue before it became a road hazard.
- Knowledgeable, courteous staff
- Fast service with minimal wait
- Safety-focused: staff flag problems before you leave
- Honest pricing on most visits
Watch out: At least one billing dispute over a same-day return charged as a three-day rental.
Services: residential propane delivery, emergency propane service, commercial industrial propane
5. True Value Rental of Brandon-Tampa FL
4.4 (27 reviews)score 68/100
True Value Rental of Brandon-Tampa scores highest on sentiment in this entire list (0.75), driven by named staff (Josh, Crystal) who handle everything from routine rentals to unusual custom setups with little notice. The review count is modest, so treat the strong average as promising rather than fully proven.
- Same-day and last-minute fulfillment
- On-site delivery, setup, and pickup included
- Fair, straightforward pricing
- Staff accommodate unusual or custom requests
Watch out: A few mentions of equipment cleanliness on arrival.
Services: residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, commercial industrial propane
6. U-Haul Moving & Storage at Citrus Park
3.9 (197 reviews)score 66/100
Citrus Park's U-Haul draws praise for quick, friendly counter service, and it holds a decent composite score built on strong review volume. The recurring issue is pricing transparency: several renters were quoted one number online and charged more at pickup.
- Friendly, helpful counter staff
- Fast checkout on straightforward rentals
- Fair treatment once issues are raised
- Clean, well-equipped facility
Watch out: Online quotes not always matching in-store charges, plus slow refund processing.
Services: residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, emergency propane service
7. U-Haul Moving & Storage at Westchase
3.7 (245 reviews)score 64/100
Westchase U-Haul gets specific praise for a staffer named Rikki going out of her way to help, and most transactions move smoothly. The propane side is the weak link here: certified attendants aren't always on duty during posted hours, so calling ahead is worth doing.
- Staff like Rikki go above and beyond
- Quick check-in and drop-off
- Fair pricing when confirmed with staff directly
- Propane sales offered on-site
Watch out: Propane refill station has been left unstaffed during posted hours; some reviewers describe rude interactions.
Services: propane tank installation, emergency propane service
8. U-Haul Moving & Storage of North Tampa
3.7 (233 reviews)score 63/100
North Tampa's U-Haul makes booking a truck or storage unit easy online, and staff are repeatedly praised by name for going out of their way. Propane hours here are inconsistent, and a few reviewers flagged installation safety issues, so this is stronger for rentals than for propane specifically.
- Easy online reservation system
- Professional, helpful staff
- Quick access to storage
- Loyal long-term truck-rental customers
Watch out: Propane hours not always honored, and hidden late fees show up in complaints.
Services: autofill monitoring, residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, autogas propane cylinder refill
9. U-Haul Moving & Storage of Historic Ybor City
3.7 (204 reviews)score 62/100
The Historic Ybor City location benefits from standout staff, Thomas and La'Shae in particular, who get singled out for efficient, warm service. It's the closest full-service option to downtown Tampa, though propane availability late in the day is a recurring sore point.
- Standout individual staff performance
- Efficient service on good days
- Propane refills available near downtown
- Knowledgeable support when reached
Watch out: Propane tanks reportedly locked up before posted closing time, plus billing and refund confusion.
Services: residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, emergency propane service, commercial industrial propane
10. U-Haul Moving & Storage of West Tampa
3.5 (220 reviews)score 60/100
West Tampa's U-Haul runs a newer fleet and offers on-site hitch installation, with named staff (Nichole, Bryan, Mike) resolving issues quickly when they're at the desk. The self-service app has been a pain point, and the desk isn't always staffed.
- Fast check-in when staffed
- Well-maintained, newer rental fleet
- On-site hitch installation
- Friendly service from named staff
Watch out: App crashes during self-pickup and an occasionally unattended front desk.
Services: residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, emergency propane service, commercial industrial propane
11. U-Haul Moving & Storage of East Tampa
3.5 (172 reviews)score 59/100
East Tampa's U-Haul is called out by reviewers as outperforming other branches nearby, with technician Dave Hudson specifically praised for prompt, polite propane fills. It handles multi-customer rushes better than some sister locations, even if pricing complaints surface occasionally.
- Staff known by name for responsiveness
- Quick service even under pressure
- Good equipment availability
- Propane fills available on-site
Watch out: Pricing runs higher than some competitors, and phone support is inconsistent.
Services: residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, emergency propane service, commercial industrial propane
12. Suburban Propane
3.3 (263 reviews)score 59/100
Suburban Propane is a dedicated propane delivery company with nearly a century of operations serving Tampa and Lakeland, built on a high-confidence score from 263 reviews. Field technicians Colin, Matt, and Jeremy earn consistent five-star praise for emergency response and clear explanations, but the back office is where trust breaks down for a meaningful share of customers.
- Field technicians praised by name for professionalism and safety
- Autofill service prevents unexpected outages for loyal subscribers
- Emergency leak repair available
- Manager Kendall responsive to billing disputes when escalated
Watch out: Complaints of unsolicited autofill enrollment, surprise bills, and multi-week gaps without gas during disputes.
Services: autofill monitoring, residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, autogas propane cylinder refill
13. U-Haul Moving & Storage at West Waters Ave
3.3 (161 reviews)score 59/100inexpensive
West Waters Ave U-Haul has staff, Manuel and Yermo specifically, who get credit for hands-on problem-solving on trailer hitches and same-day repairs. The booking system and fee transparency are the weak points, with modest rentals sometimes turning into much larger charges.
- Staff go above and beyond on problem-solving
- Same-day trailer hitch repair and installation
- Full range of moving supplies in stock
- Quick process when systems cooperate
Watch out: Hidden fees and outdated booking systems are recurring complaints.
Services: autofill monitoring, residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, emergency propane service · Price: inexpensive
14. United Rentals
4.3 (19 reviews)score 58/100
This United Rentals location carries a 4.3 rating but from only 19 reviews, so the low confidence score reflects thin data rather than poor performance. Recent reviewers note the business has gotten better since earlier complaints, with quick equipment swaps and courteous staff.
- Quick equipment replacement on failure
- Courteous, responsive staff
- Long-standing reliability
- Visible improvement over past issues
Watch out: Older reviews mention dirty equipment and unclear billing, worth confirming terms upfront.
Services: residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, commercial industrial propane
15. United Rentals
3.8 (32 reviews)score 56/100
This United Rentals branch has a mixed record: older and some recent reviews praise courteous delivery and named staff, but newer complaints center on equipment promised as available and then not delivered. Confirming stock by phone before counting on it is the safe move.
- On-time delivery when confirmed
- Courteous drivers
- Responsive staff by name
- Equipment in good working condition
Watch out: Overbooking and stock mismatches lead to wasted calls and surprise charges.
Services: residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, commercial industrial propane