Florida Propane Supplier Guide
Menu
Request delivery

Propane supplier in Sarasota

52 propane suppliers in Sarasota, Florida ranked on Google reviews. Find local delivery and service. How we score ›

THE BEST 15 PROPANE SUPPLIERS IN SARASOTA, FLORIDA

Browse by service

Automatic Delivery & Tank MonitoringCylinder Refill & ExchangeCommercial & Industrial Propane Supply24/7 Emergency Propane ServicePropane Tank Installation & LeasingResidential Propane Delivery

Top-scored propane supplier in Sarasota

51 businesses in Sarasota. See all 51 on the map ›

Flanders Gas Inc
#1
74

Flanders Gas Inc

4.4(66)✓ Google-verified

Flanders Gas earns strong loyalty for quick service, fair pricing that charges only for what customers use, and staff who know the work well. The main friction is outdated billing: no online payment portal or invoicing, which one customer found frustrating enough to recommend competitors. During hurricane season demand surges, wait times can stretch, though most reviews praise their emergency reliability.

Propane Tank Installation & LeasingResidential Propane DeliveryCylinder Refill & Exchange
View profile
Tractor Supply Co.
#2
71

Tractor Supply Co.

4.2(329)✓ Google-verifiedPublishes prices

Staff often impress with knowledge and willingness to help, and the Fruitville Road location maintains good inventory and cleanliness. However, propane refill service has faced repeated complaints about refusals near closing time and delivery orders go unfulfilled or arrive unpredictably, leaving customers frustrated with reliability.

Residential Propane DeliveryCommercial & Industrial Propane SupplyAutomatic Delivery & Tank Monitoring
View profile
Suburban Propane
#3
70

Suburban Propane

3.9(217)✓ Google-verified

Most visits go smoothly with staff who remember you and answer questions thoroughly. Margaret handles office issues, Heath and Randy earn praise for attentiveness even in extreme heat, and Georgiana manages properties across Siesta Key with reliable communication. A clear fault line splits the reviews: the many who get called for confirmation and leave satisfied, versus a smaller group who experienced unwanted deliveries, billing surprises, or service charges that felt like double-charging. The business claims nearly 100 years in operation and serves Sarasota and Zolfo Springs. Their stated pricing sometimes fails to match the final bill, ranging from $4 to $8.17 per gallon in recent complaints. Tank monitoring works well for most, but a few reports suggest gauge failures and unresolved maintenance go unaddressed for years.

Propane Tank Installation & LeasingResidential Propane DeliveryCylinder Refill & Exchange
View profile
United Rentals
#4
64

United Rentals

4.3(21)✓ Google-verified

Most renters report smooth pickups, well-kept equipment, and staff who go beyond standard service to meet deadlines. A handful of older complaints centered on last-minute cancellations and form-filling surprises, though stronger recent reviews suggest more reliable handling.

Propane Tank Installation & LeasingResidential Propane DeliveryCommercial & Industrial Propane Supply
View profile
U-Haul Moving & Storage of North Sarasota
#5
62

U-Haul Moving & Storage of North Sarasota

3.8(139)✓ Google-verified

Aaron and several named staff members deliver standout, patient service that keeps repeat customers coming back; the North Sarasota location itself is praised for cleanliness and efficiency. However, truck pickup conditions are sometimes poor (unwashed interiors, debris left behind), reservation wait times have frustrated renters, and U-Box tracking and delivery reliability remains problematic. Staff reception lapses and surprise mileage charges add friction to otherwise smooth transactions. The business thrives on individual staff performance rather than consistent systems. U-Box containers in particular appear to cause frustration when delays occur, and renters report no transparency about shipment timing. Cleanliness standards slip between rentals, and returning trucks can be unnecessarily complicated when multiple locations reject the same vehicle.

Propane Tank Installation & LeasingResidential Propane DeliveryCylinder Refill & Exchange
View profile
Detweiler's Propane Gas Service, Lc
#6
61

Detweiler's Propane Gas Service, Lc

3.9(58)✓ Google-verified

Most customers praise Detweiler's technicians and office staff for friendliness and quick work, particularly on tank installations and refills. Several long-term users highlight reliable service and easy auto-pay scheduling. However, recent complaints center on a driver refusing delivery over lawn conditions, delayed communication on installation projects, and terse phone interactions that frustrated customers seeking refunds or clarification.

Propane Tank Installation & LeasingResidential Propane DeliveryCylinder Refill & Exchange
View profile
U-Haul Moving & Storage of South Sarasota
#7
60

U-Haul Moving & Storage of South Sarasota

3.5(209)✓ Google-verified

Most visits go smoothly, with staff praised for friendliness and flexibility on truck rentals and hitches. Propane refills and basic services work well. But missed appointments, unexplained charges (overmileage, drop-off fees, cash refusal), and inconsistent professionalism at check-in sour the experience for a meaningful slice of customers. Manager Alicia and technician Aaron earn individual praise, yet accountability gaps remain.

Propane Tank Installation & LeasingResidential Propane DeliveryCylinder Refill & Exchange
View profile
Midco Petroleum
#8
56 low data

Midco Petroleum

4.4(14)✓ Google-verified

Long-standing family business built strong loyalty over years with dependable delivery and responsive emergency service. Recent reviews indicate they may have stopped offering propane or narrowed their scope, making current service availability unclear despite a strong track record.

Propane Tank Installation & LeasingResidential Propane DeliveryCylinder Refill & Exchange
View profile
Sunoco
#9
51 low data

Sunoco

3.2(38)✓ Google-verified

This Sarasota Sunoco location is consistently flagged for payment equipment failures, cleanliness issues, and prices well above competitors. Reviewers report malfunctioning card readers, missing receipts, and pumps that force customers inside to pay. Multiple complaints span years without apparent resolution.

Cylinder Refill & ExchangeCommercial & Industrial Propane SupplyResidential Propane Delivery
View profile

Get quotes from our featured partners in Sarasota

How many quotes would you like?

When you send this enquiry, you agree that we share it with providers who are relevant to your request.

Your inquiry may be shared with partner providers to complete the work, and we may earn a referral fee. Our rankings are based on our published scoring method and are not affected by referral fees.

Last updated 2026-09-04