THE BEST 15 PROPANE SUPPLIERS IN CAPE CORAL, FLORIDA

★★★★★4.5 (718 reviews)score 77/100

77/100

Tractor Supply tops the list on the strength of its broad store experience: reviewers consistently praise the friendly staff, clean aisles, and wide range of farm, pet, and garden goods across 718 reviews at 4.5 stars. Propane refill is offered on-site, though it's the one part of the visit that draws real frustration from customers.

• Wide selection of farm, pet, and garden supplies
• Friendly, helpful staff and clean store
• On-site dog wash and pet amenities
• Convenient location with extended hours

Watch out: Propane refill service itself is inconsistent, with several reviewers reporting failed attempts and mixed staff responses.

Services: commercial industrial propane, autofill monitoring, residential propane delivery, propane tank installation

★★★★☆3.9 (432 reviews)score 71/100moderate

71/100

BJ's earns its spot with strong bulk pricing and a well-stocked, fresh inventory across groceries and general merchandise, backed by 432 reviews at 3.9 stars, with propane tank exchange as a convenient add-on to a bigger shopping trip. Sentiment leans positive overall despite some gripes about cleanliness.

• Competitive bulk pricing
• Wide product selection across categories
• Fresh, well-curated inventory

Watch out: Some visitors flag cart and bathroom cleanliness as a letdown.

Services: residential propane delivery · Price: moderate

★★★★★4.8 (22 reviews)score 71/100

71/100

Paradise Propane is a small, owner-led operation that punches above its size: 21 of 22 reviews are five stars, with customers naming owner Shaun and technician Hector for going out of their way on delivery and service. The review volume is lower than the big chains, but the consistency of praise for punctuality and fair pricing stands out.

• On-time, responsive delivery
• Named staff (Shaun, Hector) praised repeatedly
• Fair, transparent pricing
• Professional, local service

Watch out: One recent reviewer couldn't get an answer during posted hours, a rare gap against an otherwise near-spotless record.

Services: propane tank installation, emergency propane service, commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery

★★★★☆4.2 (97 reviews)score 67/100

67/100

RCS & Company suits propane-fueled generator work best: with 97 reviews and high-confidence data, most customers report fast dispatch and skilled technicians like Rafael, Miguel, and Daniel who explain issues clearly before repairing. A minority of reviews describe steep service fees or follow-up problems on more complex jobs.

• Same-day or next-day technician dispatch
• Named technicians consistently praised for professionalism
• Certified across major generator brands (Generac, Kohler, Cummins)
• Clear testing and explanation before repair

Watch out: Service charges in the $375-500 range have drawn complaints when repairs didn't fully resolve the issue.

Services: residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, autofill monitoring, emergency propane service

★★★★☆4.3 (88 reviews)score 65/100

65/100

Lee County Plumbing & Supply is a family-owned shop known first for sourcing hard-to-find plumbing parts, with propane tank exchange offered alongside, rated 4.3 stars from 88 reviews at high confidence. Loyal repeat customers praise the staff's problem-solving, though the propane side has drawn specific complaints.

• Staff source rare parts other stores don't stock
• Strong problem-solving and customer service
• Family-owned with a loyal repeat customer base

Watch out: Cash-only payment and disputes over refill weight and pricing ($31 per refill) have frustrated some propane customers.

Services: commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, autofill monitoring

★★★★☆3.6 (76 reviews)score 58/100

58/100

Suburban Propane brings the reach of a national delivery company, and the technicians who show up, Dave among them, earn real praise for solving problems other providers missed, reflected in 76 reviews at 3.6 stars. The office side is the weak link, with scheduling and billing issues surfacing often enough to matter.

• Experienced, courteous technicians
• Professional one-day installations
• Long operating history and local office presence

Watch out: Appointment no-shows, billing confusion, and slow emergency response are recurring complaints.

Services: propane tank installation, emergency propane service, commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery

★★★★★4.5 (4 reviews)score 45/100

45/100

This Blue Rhino location at the Publix near Veterans and Santa Barbara is a convenient tank-exchange stop, with just a handful of reviews so far, all positive, citing competitive pricing and quick service. It's a low-confidence read given the small sample, but useful for a fast swap while grocery shopping.

• Convenient Publix location
• Competitive tank exchange pricing

Watch out: Only a handful of reviews exist, so this is a thin data set to judge by.

Services: commercial industrial propane, autogas propane cylinder refill, residential propane delivery, propane tank installation

★★★★★5 (1 reviews)score 40/100

40/100

This Amerigas location lists a full menu of propane services, from tank exchange and cylinder refill to leak checks, recertification, and fleet fueling. Customer feedback is limited to a single five-star review, so treat this as a promising but largely unproven option.

• Tank exchange and cylinder refill on-site
• Leak checks and tank recertification offered

Watch out: Just one review is on record, so there isn't much evidence to judge consistency.

Services: commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, autofill monitoring

score 34/100

34/100

This Amerigas branch covers cylinder refill, tank exchange, delivery, installation, and commercial fleet refueling across the Cape Coral area. There's no review history yet to confirm real-world service quality, so it's included for its service range rather than a track record.

• Wide service range under one roof
• Cylinder exchange and delivery available
• Commercial fleet refueling offered

Watch out: No customer reviews are on file yet for this location.

Services: commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery, autogas propane cylinder refill, propane tank installation

score 34/100

34/100

This Amerigas hub stands out for specialty offerings like AutoGas conversion and agricultural propane alongside standard tank exchange, refill, and delivery. As with the other unrated Amerigas locations, there's no review base yet to back up the service claims.

• National chain backing
• Agricultural and fleet propane services
• Tank recertification and leak checks on-site

Watch out: No reviews are available yet for this specific location.

Services: residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, autofill monitoring, autogas propane cylinder refill

score 34/100

34/100

This Burnt Store area Blue Rhino operates daily for tank exchange and offers both home delivery and business propane supply. It has no review history yet, so it's listed on service availability rather than a proven track record.

• Open seven days a week
• Tank exchange available
• Home delivery and business supply offered

Watch out: No customer reviews are on record for this location yet.

Services: propane tank installation, autofill monitoring, residential propane delivery, autogas propane cylinder refill

score 32/100

32/100

This Amerigas location states it covers exchange, refill, residential and commercial delivery, tank installation, and emergency service. There's no review data yet, so the service list is the main thing to go on for now.

• Full-service propane exchange and refill
• Residential, commercial, and emergency service types

Watch out: No reviews are available yet for this location.

Services: commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, autofill monitoring

score 32/100

32/100

This Blue Rhino spot offers straightforward propane tank exchange and delivery for homes and businesses in the Cape Coral area. It hasn't built up a review history yet, so it's an unproven but available option.

• Tank exchange for homes and businesses
• Delivery service listed

Watch out: No customer reviews are on record yet.

Services: residential propane delivery, commercial industrial propane, autogas propane cylinder refill

score 30/100

30/100

The Home Depot's propane exchange kiosk is a familiar option for a quick tank swap while running other errands, though there isn't yet enough recent review activity to gauge consistency.

• Convenient big-box location for errands
• Standard tank exchange service

Watch out: Not enough recent reviews exist to judge service reliability.

Services: residential propane delivery, autogas propane cylinder refill

score 30/100

30/100

This Blue Rhino location claims residential and commercial delivery alongside standard tank exchange across Florida, but review evidence is limited, so it's best treated as a backup option until more feedback comes in.

• Tank exchange available
• Residential and commercial delivery listed

Watch out: Limited review evidence makes this hard to fully vet yet.

Services: residential propane delivery, commercial industrial propane, autogas propane cylinder refill