Best propane suppliers in Cape Coral

★★★★★4.5 (705 reviews)score 76/100

76/100

Tractor Supply pulls the top composite score in Cape Coral on the strength of a large review base (705 reviews at 4.5 stars) and staff who get called out by name for good service. It's less a dedicated propane shop and more a general store that happens to fill tanks, which explains why the propane side draws more mixed feedback than the rest of the business.

• Wide selection beyond propane (farm, pet, hardware)
• Staff frequently praised by name
• Open 7 days a week
• Large, well-established review base

Watch out: Propane refill service gets flagged as inconsistent, with some customers turned away on different visits for different reasons.

Services: autofill monitoring, emergency propane service, autogas propane cylinder refill, commercial industrial propane

★★★★☆4.4 (85 reviews)score 69/100

69/100

Lee County Plumbing & Supply earns the highest confidence rating on this list, built on 85 reviews at 4.4 stars and a team that reviewers describe as honest and willing to hunt down obscure parts rather than upsell new equipment. Propane tank exchange is available alongside the plumbing side, though it's not their sole focus.

• Staff (Dionne, Alba, Dee) praised repeatedly for patience and honesty
• Sources hard-to-find plumbing parts other stores skip
• Fast turnaround and problem-solving on old fixtures
• Family-owned, personable service

Watch out: Cash-only payment frustrates regulars, and some dispute tank fill amounts and pricing; RV propane refills aren't offered.

Services: residential propane delivery, emergency propane service, autogas propane cylinder refill, commercial industrial propane

★★★★★4.8 (21 reviews)score 67/100

67/100

Paradise Propane is the highest-rated dedicated propane business here, at 4.8 stars, with reviewers consistently citing on-time delivery and fair pricing across a service area stretching from Fort Myers to Naples. The review count is smaller than the big-box competitors, but the sentiment is the most consistently positive on this list.

• On-time delivery reported consistently
• Owner Shaun and technician Hector singled out for going the extra mile
• Fair, transparent pricing
• Wide service area from Fort Myers to Naples

Watch out: One recent review flagged an hour wait with no answer during posted business hours.

Services: residential propane delivery, autofill monitoring, propane tank installation, emergency propane service

★★★★☆3.9 (413 reviews)score 67/100moderate

67/100

BJ's Wholesale Club carries the largest review volume on this list at 413 reviews, and the gas station draws praise for quick checkout and reasonable pump prices. The 3.9-star average reflects general warehouse gripes more than propane-specific problems, so treat it as a convenient fuel stop rather than a specialist.

• Reasonable fuel prices
• Quick app-based checkout
• Pump lines rarely crowded
• Friendly staff at the pumps

Watch out: Limited product variety and prices that run higher than competitors like Sam's Club.

Services: residential propane delivery, autofill monitoring, commercial industrial propane · Price: moderate

★★★★☆4.2 (93 reviews)score 66/100

66/100

RCS & Company draws strong praise for fast dispatch and technicians like Miguel, Daniel, Carlos, and Fernando, with owner Rafael personally following up after jobs. The 4.2-star average across 93 reviews sits alongside real complaints about pricing and warranty follow-through, so it's a stronger fit for installation work than routine tank fills.

• Named technicians consistently praised for skill and politeness
• Owner personally calls after job completion
• Bilingual staff (English and Spanish)
• Quick dispatch times

Watch out: Diagnostic visits and repairs run expensive, and one warranty dispute went unresolved despite nearly $4,500 spent.

Services: residential propane delivery, commercial industrial propane

★★★★☆3.6 (75 reviews)score 57/100

57/100

Suburban Propane can deliver strong individual service, with technicians like Dave, Tryston, and Garrett and office staff like Susie earning specific praise for same-day installs and problem-solving. The 3.6-star average across 75 reviews reflects real organizational issues that show up often enough to matter.

• Same-day tank installation and inspections available
• Technicians praised for catching problems others miss
• Emergency and remote monitoring services offered
• Office staff willing to work around scheduling obstacles

Watch out: Reviewers describe the company as bureaucratic and expensive, with no-shows, billing errors, and week-long delivery waits reported.

Services: residential propane delivery, autofill monitoring, propane tank installation, emergency propane service

★★★★★4.5 (4 reviews)score 44/100

44/100

This Blue Rhino location at the Publix near Veterans and Santa Barbara gets a clean 4.5-star rating, though from only 4 reviews so treat it as a light data point rather than a firm track record. The one detailed review calls out competitive exchange pricing and fast service.

• Convenient Publix location
• Competitive tank exchange pricing

Watch out: Very few reviews to date, so the rating carries low confidence.

Services: autogas propane cylinder refill, commercial industrial propane, propane tank installation, residential propane delivery

★★★★★5 (1 reviews)score 39/100

39/100

This Amerigas location lists a broad menu, tank exchange, cylinder refill, delivery, installation, recertification, leak checks, and fleet services, and its single review is a perfect 5 stars. With just one review, this is more a placeholder for service range than a proven reputation.

• Full range of services claimed: exchange, refill, delivery, installation
• Leak checks and tank recertification on-site

Watch out: Only one review on record, so there isn't enough evidence yet to judge consistency.

Services: commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery

score 34/100

34/100

This Amerigas branch lists cylinder refill, tank exchange, delivery, installation, and fleet refueling across Florida, but has zero reviews so far. It's included for its stated service range rather than any track record.

• Wide service range listed
• Cylinder exchange available
• Fleet refueling capability stated

Watch out: No reviews yet, so there's no customer feedback to verify service quality.

Services: autogas propane cylinder refill, commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery

score 34/100

34/100

This Blue Rhino location serves the Burnt Store area of Cape Coral with daily operation and both home and business delivery, according to its listing. No reviews are on file yet, so this is based on stated services only.

• Operates 7 days a week
• Tank exchange available
• Serves both home delivery and business supply

Watch out: No reviews on record, so performance is unverified.

Services: autogas propane cylinder refill, commercial industrial propane, propane tank installation, autofill monitoring

score 34/100

34/100

This Amerigas hub lists an unusually wide service menu, including AutoGas conversion and agricultural propane alongside standard tank exchange and delivery. Review evidence is absent, so the national brand backing is the main thing to go on here.

• National chain backing
• Wide service range including agricultural and fleet
• Tank recertification and leak checks on-site

Watch out: No customer reviews available to confirm real-world service quality.

Services: commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery

score 32/100

32/100

This Amerigas location states it covers propane exchange, refill, residential and commercial delivery, tank installation, and emergency service. There's no review history yet, so it's listed on the strength of its stated service range rather than proven performance.

• Full-service exchange and refill claimed
• Multiple service types: residential, commercial, emergency

Watch out: No reviews on file, so there's nothing yet to confirm reliability.

Services: autogas propane cylinder refill, commercial industrial propane, propane tank installation, autofill monitoring

score 32/100

32/100

This Blue Rhino location offers tank exchange and delivery for homes and businesses in Cape Coral. With no reviews yet, it's a straightforward listing rather than a proven performer.

• Tank exchange and delivery for both homes and businesses

Watch out: No review evidence yet to assess service quality.

Services: commercial industrial propane, residential propane delivery

score 30/100

30/100

The Home Depot propane exchange kiosk offers the convenience of swapping a tank during a regular hardware run. There isn't enough review data yet to say how reliable the exchange process is at this specific location.

• Convenient exchange while running other errands

Watch out: No reviews on record, so recent service quality is unverified.

Services: residential propane delivery, autogas propane cylinder refill, commercial industrial propane

score 30/100

30/100

This Blue Rhino location states it handles both residential and commercial propane delivery in Cape Coral alongside standard tank exchange. Review detail isn't available, so it's included for its stated service scope.

• Tank exchange service
• Residential and commercial delivery options

Watch out: No reviews available yet, so service consistency can't be verified.

Services: autogas propane cylinder refill, commercial industrial propane, propane tank installation, autofill monitoring