Guide to propane cylinder refill and exchange in Fort Myers: how the service works, what to check before you buy, and 46 local options ranked.
Cylinder refill and exchange covers the small stuff most households and businesses actually run on: 20 lb grill tanks, forklift cylinders, patio heater bottles, and small camping canisters. You either swap your empty tank for a full one on the spot, or hand over your own cylinder to be weighed, inspected, and refilled while you wait. Fort Myers has 46 businesses offering some version of this, from hardware stores and gas stations with an exchange cage out front to dedicated propane dealers that do refills on site.
The two methods matter for different reasons. Exchange is fast and works anywhere the cage is stocked, but you're trading your tank's condition and fill level for whatever is in the cage that day, and exchange tanks are often filled to 15-17 lb rather than a full 20 lb to account for weight and safety margins. A direct refill, done by weight at a propane dealer, generally gets you closer to a true full tank and lets you keep the same cylinder, which matters if it's a newer tank or has a specific valve or gauge.
Before choosing a location, check that cylinders are inspected for dents, rust, and valve damage, that the scale or meter is calibrated, and that staff are trained to spot an expired certification date (tanks need requalification every 12 years, or 5 years after that). Our ranking weighs these factors along with pricing transparency, wait times, and how consistently a business fills to the correct weight. See the ranked guide to Fort Myers propane suppliers for how the 46 options compare, and read our methodology for the full scoring breakdown.
Find cylinder refill & exchange in Fort Myers in your area
No cost, no obligation. Tell us what you need and we'll connect you with suitable propane suppliers.
We found 46 businesses offering cylinder refill & exchange in Fort Myers; 44 met the criteria for the scored directory. The order weighs each business's overall score by how much of its reviewed work is cylinder refill & exchange, so a lower-scored specialist can rank above a higher-scored generalist.
Staff earn consistent praise for friendliness and helpfulness across this general retailer that also offers propane services. One customer dispute shows management responsiveness gaps, but the bulk of recent reviews highlight courteous service, clean facilities, and fair prices on both animal care and propane supplies.
Tractor Supply in North Fort Myers earns strong marks for staff friendliness and a straightforward shopping experience, with customers appreciating the range of farm, ranch, and garage supplies at moderate prices. Stock management has been a recurring frustration, with reviewers noting empty shelves and damaged merchandise, though the store remains convenient for regular errands.
Reviewers consistently report quick, efficient service with staff who go beyond standard work. Technicians arrive on time, handle installations and emergency fills with care, and office staff like Jennifer and Cindy earn specific praise for coordinating schedules and expediting urgent calls. Honesty stands out: one customer describes how Blossman corrected a competitor's faulty tank reading and sided with the homeowner against an expensive upsell.
South Florida Gas delivers fast, friendly service most of the time, with staff like Nikki, Christine, and Tracey earning repeated praise for handling emergencies and walking customers through new accounts. The app-based tank monitoring and same-day emergency fills work well for many. However, some hit scheduling snags and billing frustration: the flat $44 per-tank refill rate (even for partial fills) riles those used to per-gallon pricing. A few customers also report the company shutting its gate early or not answering phones, though most find staff responsive. Recent changes under Thompson Gas ownership have left some longstanding customers sour on communication between departments and appointment follow-through, though the day-to-day friendliness remains. The business clearly invests in standout customer service and does pull off last-minute rescues, but operational consistency has wavered.
Most customers praise the Fort Myers store for friendly staff, clean layout, and solid stock of feed and supplies. A few report frustrating phone calls and online order issues that went unresolved.
Find cylinder refill & exchange in Fort Myers in your area
No cost, no obligation. Tell us what you need and we'll connect you with suitable propane suppliers.
Renters consistently praise the staff's friendliness and efficient handling of vehicle pickups and drop-offs, with several noting cheerful adaptability to changes. Propane refills remain a weak point: multiple reviewers arrived to find no staff available to fill tanks, and truck rentals are marred by unexpected fuel surcharges and equipment fees that take weeks to dispute and resolve.
Many customers praise the location for friendly staff, clean trucks, and smooth check-in processes. However, serious incidents involving damaged customer belongings, botched trailer loading, and refused insurance claims create significant risk for renters relying on their service or moving labor. Staff named Kash and Frost receive individual mentions for good service. Trailers and trucks are described as well-maintained and cleanly kept. Property maintenance has visibly improved over recent months, per one reviewer's comparison. Still, damage disputes and customer service failures during conflicts are documented.
Staff respond fast to routine refills and emergencies alike, with drive-through convenience and direct technician contact. One reviewer paid over $6 per gallon for cylinder refills and felt overcharged; another community project waited weeks for a follow-up quote after an initial consultation.
Ferrellgas delivers sharp contrasts: some reviewers praise quick emergency response and friendly staff, particularly after hurricanes. Others face weeks-long waits, billing mix-ups, and little local accountability from a corporate call center.
Two five-star reviews reflect strong satisfaction with responsive office staff and a named technician (Hugo) who explained work clearly. Evidence is limited to two recent reviews.
Five-star reviews highlight fast, easy refills at fair prices with knowledgeable staff. Limited review volume constrains confidence in long-term consistency.
On-time, efficient refills at fair rates when staff are engaged; however, service reliability swings sharply. Half the reviews praise speed and friendliness, the other half describe unhelpful staff and abandoned customers who left for competitors like Tractor Supply.
Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.
With limited review evidence, this Fort Myers location appears to stock propane reliably. Service details are sparse.
One reviewer reported the kiosk rejected credit cards with no staff available to help, leaving them unable to complete a propane purchase.
One five-star reviewer called the service useful and convenient. Evidence is limited to a single brief review.
Blue Rhino operates in Fort Myers with propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business delivery. Review evidence is limited.
Amerigas operates as a multi-service propane provider in Fort Myers with a broad service menu spanning tank exchange, delivery, installation, and commercial supply. Review evidence is limited; the business's website lists tank exchange, cylinder refill, delivery, installation, recertification, leak checks, and commercial propane among their offerings.
Two customers gave five-star ratings. One praised the staff and truck service; the other expressed straightforward satisfaction with propane supply. Detail is limited from these brief reviews.
All three recent reviews report negative interactions. Customers cited technicians who refused to complete work, staff who were dismissive and rude, and a pattern of no callbacks and slow response.
Review evidence is limited. Amerigas lists propane delivery, tank installation, cylinder refills, emergency service, and AutoGas on their website; they serve Florida and operate from The Forum in Fort Myers with published daily hours.
Review detail for this location is currently limited. Amerigas lists propane exchange, refill, delivery, installation, and commercial services on their website; they operate in Diplomat, North Fort Myers, with stated coverage across Florida.
Find cylinder refill & exchange in Fort Myers in your area
No cost, no obligation. Tell us what you need and we'll connect you with suitable propane suppliers.
One customer needed refill or exchange but left unable to do either: the location only exchanges tanks at a premium, runs short on stock, and declined cash payment. No acknowledgment of the inconvenience.
Two one-star reviews cite chronic inability to reach the business by phone or online. Customers report frustration with overseas call routing, difficulty paying bills, and no response to service requests even after hurricane damage. Evidence is limited to two reviews, both over a year old.
Review text is not available for this location. Blue Rhino operates from Hancock in North Fort Myers and claims to offer propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business supply across Florida.
Review evidence for this location is not available. The business claims to offer propane tank exchange, cylinder refill, delivery, installation, leak checks, and commercial supply across Florida. Check current hours and service details directly with the Fort Myers location.
Review evidence is limited. Amerigas Propane Exchange operates in Fort Myers and their website lists tank exchange, cylinder refill, delivery, installation, leak checks, recertification, temporary heat, AutoGas, and commercial propane services across Florida.
Review evidence for this location is limited. The business operates from Omni, Fort Myers, and their website lists tank exchange, residential and commercial delivery services. Check availability in your area before ordering.
Review evidence is limited for this location. Blue Rhino operates in Fort Myers and states it offers tank exchange, home delivery, and business propane supply, though specific customer experience details are not available.
Review evidence for Blue Rhino Propane Exchange in Fort Myers is limited. The business lists propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business delivery on its website; open 7 days a week. Without individual review text, specific strengths or concerns cannot be assessed.
Review evidence is limited. Amerigas Propane Exchange operates in Fort Myers and their website lists tank exchange, cylinder refill, delivery, installation, leak checks, recertification, temporary heat, AutoGas, and commercial propane services across Florida.
Review evidence for this location is not available. The business claims to offer propane tank exchange, cylinder refill, delivery, installation, leak checks, and commercial supply across Florida. Check current hours and service details directly with the Fort Myers location.
Review evidence for Blue Rhino is limited. The business operates in Fort Myers with listed hours and offers propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business delivery according to their website.
Review evidence for this location is limited; no customer feedback is currently available to assess service quality or reliability. Visit their website or call ahead to learn about specific offerings and pricing in your area.
Review evidence for Blue Rhino is limited. The business operates in Fort Myers with listed hours and offers propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business delivery according to their website.
Review evidence for this location is not available. The business claims to offer propane tank exchange, cylinder refill, delivery, installation, leak checks, and commercial supply across Florida. Check current hours and service details directly with the Fort Myers location.
Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.
Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.
Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.
Review evidence is limited. Amerigas Propane Exchange lists tank exchange, cylinder refill, delivery, installation, and commercial propane among their North Fort Myers services; see their website for specific pricing and availability.
Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.
Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.
Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.
Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.
We may pass your enquiry to partner providers who can do the work, and may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based only on our published method and are not affected by referral fees.
Last updated 2026-08-04