Propane supplier in Carrollwood

Find propane suppliers serving Carrollwood, Florida. 109 providers cover the area, with 40 based locally. Average rating 3.3.

Propane service in Carrollwood draws from a mix of local operators and nearby suppliers across the Tampa area. Forty providers are based right in the community, with 109 total covering the neighborhood including operations from U-Haul Moving & Storage locations at Citrus Park, North Tampa, and West Waters Ave. The closest supplier sits about 5.5 km away, making access straightforward for residential and commercial needs.

Providers serving: 128
Avg rating: 3.2★
Nearest provider: 3.7 km
Based in Carrollwood: 51

Top-scored propane suppliers serving Carrollwood

Ranked by recent Google reviews, weighted for proximity to Carrollwood. How we score ›

U-Haul Moving & Storage of North Tampa

3.7(236)✓ Google-verified

U-Haul North Tampa draws mixed reactions. Regular customers praise fast truck rental, easy online booking, and standout staff like Dayna and Dana who solve problems. However, complaints center on inconsistent service, poor follow-up after failures (particularly with trailer wiring installation), unclear fees (including $15 late-payment charges), and occasional customer-service friction around language access. The propane service also draws criticism for hours posted online not matching actual closing time.

24/7 Emergency Propane ServiceResidential Propane DeliveryAutomatic Delivery & Tank Monitoring

View profile

U-Haul Moving & Storage at Citrus Park

3.9(199)✓ Google-verified

Most visits result in friendly service and quick turnarounds, with several staff members earning specific praise for patience and going beyond their duties. However, a meaningful minority encounter serious friction: quoted prices balloon at pickup, vehicles booked online vanish from inventory, payment systems hold funds without releasing rentals, and return processing drags on. The brake controller installation is clean work at a fair cost.

Residential Propane DeliveryPropane Tank Installation & LeasingCylinder Refill & Exchange

View profile

59 low data

Gas Guru LLC

4.4(11)✓ Google-verified

Gas Guru answers phones on weekends when competitors don't and arrives same-day for propane emergencies. Nick and his crew handle leak repairs, tank moves, and appliance hookups quickly and fairly, though non-urgent requests may go unanswered.

24/7 Emergency Propane ServiceResidential Propane DeliveryAutomatic Delivery & Tank Monitoring

View profile

U-Haul Moving & Storage at West Waters Ave

3.3(161)✓ Google-verified

Reviewers praise staff members like Manuel and Yermo for hands-on help, especially with trailer hitches and problem-solving. However, the location is plagued by system failures, opaque fees that turn modest rentals into hundreds of dollars, and unpredictable customer service-some staff are dismissive or indifferent when customers need support.

24/7 Emergency Propane ServiceResidential Propane DeliveryAutomatic Delivery & Tank Monitoring

View profile

32 low data

Blue Rhino Propane Exchange

No rating yet

Review evidence is limited. Blue Rhino Propane Exchange operates from Carrollwood and their website lists propane tank exchange, home delivery, and business delivery services.

Residential Propane DeliveryCommercial & Industrial Propane SupplyCylinder Refill & Exchange

View profile

40 low data

Propane Refill at U-Haul

2.4(5)✓ Google-verifiedPublishes prices

Low review count and poor ratings (2.4 average, 60% one-to-two-star) point to persistent issues. Reviewers report staff citing wrong tank age limits, dismissive service, and posted hours not kept.

24/7 Emergency Propane ServiceCylinder Refill & ExchangeCommercial & Industrial Propane Supply

View profile

43 low data

Propane Refill at U-Haul

1.0(5)✓ Google-verifiedPublishes prices

All five reviews rate this location one star. Customers report staff who ignore walk-ins, a sole certified technician working unpredictable shifts despite published hours, refusals to refill in rain despite covered equipment, and equipment out of service. One reviewer praised a manager named Dan for responsiveness.

Cylinder Refill & ExchangeCommercial & Industrial Propane SupplyResidential Propane Delivery

View profile

30 low data

Blue Rhino Propane Exchange

No rating yet

Review evidence is limited for this location. Blue Rhino operates a propane tank exchange and delivery service in Carrollwood, open 7 days a week. Their website claims service across Florida.

Residential Propane DeliveryCylinder Refill & Exchange

View profile

39 low data

AmeriGas Propane Exchange

4.0(1)✓ Google-verified

Limited review evidence available: this location scores 4.0 across one verified Google review. The business lists tank exchange, delivery, grill refills, installation, and maintenance for both residential and commercial customers in the Tampa area.

Commercial & Industrial Propane SupplyResidential Propane DeliveryPropane Tank Installation & Leasing

View profile

#10

40 low data

AmeriGas Propane Exchange

5.0(1)✓ Google-verified

One Google review gave AmeriGas Propane Exchange a perfect five-star rating, though limited review evidence is available. The business lists broad residential and commercial propane services in the Tampa area.

Residential Propane DeliveryCylinder Refill & ExchangeCommercial & Industrial Propane Supply

View profile

#11

40 low data

Amerigas Propane Exchange

5.0(1)

One five-star review supports this business. Limited review evidence means caution on broader claims, but the company's website states it handles residential delivery, tank installation, grill exchange, and commercial propane supply across Tampa.

24/7 Emergency Propane ServiceAutomatic Delivery & Tank MonitoringCylinder Refill & Exchange

View profile

#12

38 low data

Amerigas Propane Exchange

1.0(1)

One reviewer reported a critical failure: the company did not deliver a promised replacement tank, made repeated broken promises, and left a leaking tank unaddressed. Evidence is limited to this single account.

24/7 Emergency Propane ServiceAutomatic Delivery & Tank MonitoringCylinder Refill & Exchange

View profile

Your inquiry may be shared with partner providers to complete the work, and we may earn a referral fee. Our rankings are based on our published scoring method and are not affected by referral fees.