Which is faster for a simple tank exchange?

Eddie's Propane Sales is built around this, with two-minute tank swaps cited as a norm rather than an exception.

Which has better pricing transparency?

Neither is complaint-free. Propane Ninja has a vocal minority reporting stacked setup, delivery, and hazard fees, while Eddie's has isolated disputes over charges exceeding its advertised $1-per-pound rate.

Which is better for a damaged or older cylinder?

Propane Ninja's named technicians are praised for careful work on aluminum tanks and complex installs, making it the better fit if your cylinder needs inspection beyond a routine swap.

Which has more reviews to judge from?

Propane Ninja has 244 reviews at a 4.9 rating, compared to Eddie's Propane Sales at 116 reviews, also rated 4.9.

Propane Ninja vs Eddie's Propane Sales: which is better for cylinder refill and exchange?

Updated 2026-08-04 · 2,934 reviewed · 485 listed · How we rank ›

Both of these Florida propane suppliers pull strong ratings from a solid volume of reviews, and both show up as real options if you just need a tank filled or swapped. The question for cylinder refill and exchange specifically comes down to speed of the transaction versus depth of technician skill, plus how each handles pricing at the counter. Our methodology weighs these fit factors alongside the raw ratings.

Verdict

For a straightforward cylinder refill or exchange where speed and predictable hours matter most, Eddie's Propane Sales fits the job better: two-minute swaps and early/late emergency access are exactly what that task calls for. If your cylinder needs more careful handling, such as an aluminum tank or something that might need a closer look during the exchange, Propane Ninja's named technicians and installation depth make it the safer pick, as long as you confirm the fee breakdown before you pay.

Which should you pick?

Pick Propane Ninja if

You want an exchange handled by named technicians who also do careful installation and inspection work
You're dealing with an aluminum tank or a cylinder that might need more than a straight swap
You value a larger review history (244 reviews) and don't mind occasionally double-checking the bill

Pick Eddie's Propane Sales if

You just need a tank swapped fast, ideally in a couple of minutes, and you're running a food truck or RV
You need an emergency refill outside normal hours, early morning or late at night
You want pricing that's mostly straightforward, with only isolated complaints about the advertised rate

Side by side

Criterion	Propane Ninja	Eddie's Propane Sales
Google rating	4.9 (244 reviews)	4.9 (116 reviews)
Services	autofill monitoring, residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, autogas propane cylinder refill	autofill monitoring, autogas propane cylinder refill, residential propane delivery, propane tank installation
Best for a fast, no-fuss exchange	Adequate, but reviews lean toward installs over quick swaps	Built for it: two-minute swaps are the stated norm
Best for a cylinder with damage or wear concerns	Stronger fit given technician skill with aluminum tanks and complex installs	Less documented for inspection-heavy or complex cylinder issues
Best for predictable, simple pricing	Risk of stacked fees confusing the total	Mostly fair pricing, with isolated disputes over advertised rate
Verification	Google-verified	Google-verified
Composite score	87	84

Google rating: Propane Ninja: 4.9 (244 reviews); Eddie's Propane Sales: 4.9 (116 reviews)
Services: Propane Ninja: autofill monitoring, residential propane delivery, propane tank installation, autogas propane cylinder refill; Eddie's Propane Sales: autofill monitoring, autogas propane cylinder refill, residential propane delivery, propane tank installation
Best for a fast, no-fuss exchange: Propane Ninja: Adequate, but reviews lean toward installs over quick swaps; Eddie's Propane Sales: Built for it: two-minute swaps are the stated norm
Best for a cylinder with damage or wear concerns: Propane Ninja: Stronger fit given technician skill with aluminum tanks and complex installs; Eddie's Propane Sales: Less documented for inspection-heavy or complex cylinder issues
Best for predictable, simple pricing: Propane Ninja: Risk of stacked fees confusing the total; Eddie's Propane Sales: Mostly fair pricing, with isolated disputes over advertised rate
Verification: Propane Ninja: Google-verified; Eddie's Propane Sales: Google-verified
Composite score: Propane Ninja: 87; Eddie's Propane Sales: 84

Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.

What reviewers say

Propane Ninja

Propane Ninja wins over most customers with skilled, personable technicians who take pride in clean, safe work. Named staff like Jose, Juan, and Francisco appear across praise repeatedly. Owner Peter listens to concerns and acts on them. But a vocal minority hit billing surprises (setup, delivery, hazard fees stacked together) and report frustrating communication gaps that persisted even after complaints.

The company shines on residential tank installs and refills, with underground placements, generator hookups, and aluminum-tank servicing all noted as strong. Bulk commercial orders and quick turnarounds during crunch also come through. Billing clarity and call-back speed remain sore points for some; others say Tara in billing has since stepped up.

Eddie's Propane Sales

Eddie and Sam serve food truck operators and families with speed most big box stores can't match; several drove over an hour knowing they'd leave satisfied. The shop fills tanks in minutes, opens late for emergencies, and handles everything from RV cylinders to pool heaters. Two reviews dispute pricing claims on the website, citing charges higher than the "$1 per pound" listed online, though the bulk of feedback praises fair costs versus major chains.

Torn between the two?

Describe your project once and get quotes from suitable propane supplier in Florida.

We may pass your enquiry to partner providers who can do the work, and may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based only on our published method and are not affected by referral fees.

FAQ

Which is faster for a simple tank exchange?: Eddie's Propane Sales is built around this, with two-minute tank swaps cited as a norm rather than an exception.
Which has better pricing transparency?: Neither is complaint-free. Propane Ninja has a vocal minority reporting stacked setup, delivery, and hazard fees, while Eddie's has isolated disputes over charges exceeding its advertised $1-per-pound rate.
Which is better for a damaged or older cylinder?: Propane Ninja's named technicians are praised for careful work on aluminum tanks and complex installs, making it the better fit if your cylinder needs inspection beyond a routine swap.
Which has more reviews to judge from?: Propane Ninja has 244 reviews at a 4.9 rating, compared to Eddie's Propane Sales at 116 reviews, also rated 4.9.